Upper Kitchen Cabinets or Open Shelves?
There are many decisions that go into a great kitchen remodel, and most kitchen planning starts with determining the right kitchen cabinetry. But what kitchen cabinetry style fits you and your home? Do we really have to have upper cabinets? And what about all these open shelves I’ve been seeing lately? Like this beautiful Arlington Heights kitchen renovation that features glass door cabinets and open shelving in addition to regular kitchen cabinetry, whether or not upper kitchen cabinets are right for you is something you need to determine when planning your kitchen renovation.
The Pros and Cons of Upper Kitchen Cabinets and Open Shelves
By Yanic Simard, Houzz Contributor
It’s a tough decision: to have upper cabinets or not? There are several advantages to going with uppers, but there’s also a lot to say about open shelves or nixing both entirely. To help you decide on what’s right for your kitchen, here’s a guide to the three most popular approaches and other options available to you.
Standard Upper Cabinets
Pros: Standard upper cabinets with doors offer plenty of storage with a clean and composed look. Cabinet styles and hardware such as pulls and knobs can conform to minimal or traditional tastes, making this a good option when going for a specific, cohesive look in a kitchen.
If your life is busy, upper cabinets conceal clutter and disorganized dishes that you may not have time to straighten up. This kitchen maintains a clean and tidy look no doubt thanks to the many upper cabinets that help keep things tucked away and off the countertops.
Cons: The main con of using upper cabinets is that they simply take up space, which can make a kitchen feel smaller, darker and more cramped. Cabinets, especially ones that go up to the ceiling, are also generally more expensive than shelves or wall finishes. Plus, cabinets (especially those you didn’t choose yourself) can express less of your personality than other options.
Pros: Replacing the upper cabinets with open shelving has become a popular trend in recent years. This approach helps a room feel a little more open while still providing storage for everyday essentials.
Placing frequently used items like plates, glasses and basic cookware on shelves keeps them in easy reach and creates a shop-like display that tells a personal story. Here, clear jars, ornamental bottles and curvaceous pots lend color and shape to the small space.
Cons: The issue with shelf uppers for some people is that the look is much busier, especially for those who have many items to stuff on shelves or who lack the confidence to style open shelving. Unattractive products may have nowhere else to go, and not everyone wants to feel as though they live in a grocery store aisle — or do the extra dusting required.
Tip: Before you tear down upper cabinets, try removing the doors to see how you feel about living with open shelves. You may even decide to keep it just like that.
No Upper Cabinets
Pros: An even newer trend is to skip upper shelves and upper cabinets. This lets you reclaim visual space and create more elbow room.
The result is a much larger- and airier-feeling kitchen, with room to hang art, install more beautiful tile or lighting, or simply enjoy a clean slate. The roofline in this kitchen prevents upper cabinetry, but imagine how cramped this space might look with a bank of uppers. It definitely wouldn’t have the bright, open, luxurious air that it does now.
Cons: The obvious con of skipping the uppers is the lack of extra storage. For serious chefs, lower cabinets may not be enough, especially without a pantry. For more casual cooks, this may simply promote eliminating clutter.
The other major concern with skipping the traditional upper cabinets is the possible resale issues down the line. If you plan on staying in your home for a long time, by all means have at it. But if you plan on staying for a shorter period and are concerned about resale value, going with standard upper cabinets is a safer bet.
Tip: There are no rules when it comes to where you stop your backsplash on a wall. Just use whole tiles (rather than cut halves or thirds of tile) and make sure they cover at least 6 inches up from the countertop to prevent food splashes from hitting your wall surface. And make sure the tile stops where the ends of the countertops do. In this example, that includes the small countertop ledges on each end.
Upper cabinets, open shelves and neither may be the most popular options, but they aren’t the only ones.
A single shelf. Use one floating shelf to store essentials while still keeping a breezy feel. Plus, a single shelf works great for capping a backsplash. A single shelf hung higher keeps items out of your sightline and offers a functional place to install LED or other undermount lighting, or a discreet spot to hide an outlet for plug-in appliances.\
Frosted glass doors. This option provides a slightly more open appearance than standard upper cabinets, which works great for mixing up your kitchen look without giving up storage. You may even be able to attach new frosted glass doors to existing cabinets instead of springing for all-new units.
Tip: Push less attractive products toward the back of the shelf, and bring beautiful glasses or dishes toward the front.
Floating uppers. There’s no rule that says uppers have to span from wall to wall. A set of uppers floating over the counter will cost less (because you can skip the fillers) and create a modern look that feels less stuffy and still provides lots of storage.
High uppers. The standard placement for upper cabinets has long been 18 inches above the counter. Modern installations now often hang 21 to 24 inches above, or even much higher, to give the work surface below more of an open feel. This reduces the amount of cabinet space within easy reach but still allows for plenty of storage for less commonly used items.
Shallow uppers. Another way to compromise between open space and closed cabinets is to use slimmer uppers that don’t project as far from the wall.
Standard cabinets are usually 12 inches deep, but the need to store bulky appliances has raised that depth to 15 inches on many cabinet lines. Returning to a 12-inch depth or choosing even shallower cabinets gives you ample space to store cans and spices, with those bread makers and slow cookers getting stashed down below or somewhere else.
Mix and match. Of course, you don’t have to stick to just one school of thought. The best approach is usually a personalized one. This kitchen, for example, mixes high uppers, an artful single shelf and open space to balance storage, decoration and a breath of fresh air.